Evaluation for the Unevaluated:
Program Evaluation 101

Module 2: What Does an Evaluation Project Look Like - Page 5 of 14

Step 1. Conceptualize the evaluation

Getting started is always the hardest part. Jack called a meeting, put out a plate of cookies, and filled a flip chart with ideas from staff. Here's his agenda:

What we know about evaluation. What we want to learn from the evalouation of Cool After School. What the City wants to get from the evaluation. How the evaluation cycle will fit into Cool After School's cycle of activities. Who will do all this work? Who will bring cookies to the next meeting.

Jack's team wondered, who is going to do all this work? Someone had to work closely with the evaluator. "How hard could it be?, Jack asked. After all, the evaluator was experienced and had a Ph.D. What else did they need?

In addition to the proper credentials, a good evaluator has some other important attributes:

Evaluation 101, Module 4 provides a checklist and detailed guidance on locating and assessing potential evaluators. Qualifications for Evaluation Consultants and Areas of Evaluator Expertise may help. You might want to scan those before moving on.

Jack and his staff developed a contract for the evaluator. It included a statement of work containing:

a red flag with the word Warning on it.
Warning! Jack was in such a hurry to finish his grant application that he went with the first evaluator he could find. It's better to seek proposals from several evaluators and choose one who seems best able to meet your needs.